Heart and Soil vs Ancestral Supplements: 4 Major Differences

If you’re comparing Heart and Soil vs. Ancestral Supplements, you’ll quickly notice that the brands have a lot in common.

Both sell grass-fed, freeze-dried organ supplements that are third-party tested. 

So the real question isn’t whether one company is “good” and the other is “bad.”

It’s where the meaningful differences actually are, and whether those differences are worth paying attention to.

The information in this blog is for educational purposes only. It is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Consult your healthcare provider if you’re seeking medical advice, diagnoses, or treatment. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Our products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

---

Key Takeaways

• The biggest differences in heart and soil vs ancestral supplements are formula design, sourcing and testing transparency, packaging, and price.
• Ancestral Supplements is currently cheaper upfront for several directly comparable products.
• Some basic formulas are very similar, while targeted formulas such as Thyroid+, Her Package, FEM, Whole Package, and MOFO take noticeably different approaches.
• Heart & Soil builds targeted formulas around both organ systems and complementary whole-food nutrients.
• Both companies use grass-fed organs and third-party testing, while Heart & Soil specifically emphasizes regenerative sourcing and publishes product-specific contaminant testing.
• Heart & Soil uses glass bottles and also provides a free online nutrition and lifestyle community.
• For shoppers who prioritize intentional formulations, regenerative sourcing, testing transparency, and the broader support ecosystem, we suggest Heart & Soil.

---

---

How Does Heart and Soil vs Ancestral Supplements Compare at a Glance?

	Heart & Soil	Ancestral Supplements
Grass-fed organs	Yes	Yes
Freeze-dried	Yes	Yes
Third-party testing	Yes	Yes
Main sourcing emphasis	Grass-fed, grass-finished regenerative farms in New Zealand, Australia, and the US	Grass-fed, pasture-raised farms in New Zealand & Australia
Targeted formulas	Often combine organs based on body systems + complementary nutrients	Large selection of individual and multi-organ glandular formulas
Personalized guidance	Yes	Yes
Free online community	Yes	No
Bottle	Glass	Plastic
Beef Organs one-time price*	$52	$48
Female formula one-time price*	Her Package: $74	FEM: $68
Male formula one-time price*	Whole Package: $68	MOFO: $62

*Current one-time purchase prices at the time of writing. Prices can change.

Heart & Soil’s Beef Organs currently contains liver, heart, pancreas, spleen, and kidney, while Ancestral’s Grass Fed Beef Organs contains the same five organs. Both provide a 30-day supply at their suggested serving size (1) (2). 

That makes heart and soil vs ancestral supplements a closer comparison than many supplement-brand matchups.

The differences become much clearer when we look at the targeted formulas.

---

1. What Is the Biggest Formula Difference?

The biggest distinction in heart and soil vs ancestral supplements is not simply how many organs are inside a bottle.

It’s how those organs are chosen.

Heart & Soil often builds formulas around two ideas:

• The traditional like-supports-like concept of consuming tissues associated with the body system you want to nourish.
• The vitamins, minerals, and naturally occurring compounds supplied by complementary organs.

That creates formulas that aren’t always obvious from the product name alone.

How Do the Female Formulas Compare?

Heart & Soil’s Her Package contains:

• Ovary
• Uterus
• Fallopian tubes
• Liver
• Kidney

Ancestral Supplements’ FEM contains:

• Ovary
• Uterus
• Fallopian tubes
• Liver
• Bone marrow

Both products provide 3,000 mg of total organ material per six-capsule serving, so this is not a case where Heart & Soil simply gives you more organs (3) (4). 

The real difference is the supporting organ.

Her Package pairs the reproductive tissues with liver and kidney, while FEM pairs them with liver and bone marrow.

Heart & Soil chose kidney because it provides selenium and other trace minerals that support antioxidant defenses, thyroid hormone metabolism, and reproductive physiology, making it a complementary organ alongside the female reproductive tissues and liver.

How Do the Male Formulas Compare?

Heart & Soil’s Whole Package contains:

• Testicle (1,500 mg)
• Liver
• Whole blood extract

Ancestral’s MOFO contains:

• Testicle (1,260 mg)
• Prostate
• Heart
• Liver
• Bone marrow

MOFO includes more individual organ types, while Whole Package contains higher amounts of a few select ingredients. 

Whole Package provides 3,000 mg of organ material per full serving, with 1,500 mg of testicle. MOFO’s current six-capsule label totals 2,460 mg, including 1,260 mg testicle plus 300 mg each of prostate, heart, liver, and bone marrow (5) (6). 

Intentional Formulation

Here is an example of our formulation philosophy.

Ancestral Supplements’ Grass Fed Beef Thyroid contains thyroid and liver. Each capsule provides 30 mg thyroid and 470 mg liver (7). 

Heart & Soil’s Grass-Fed Thyroid+ combines (8):

• 1,400 mg liver
• 1,400 mg kidney
• 200 mg thyroid

Why add kidney?

Kidney is one of the most selenium-rich bovine organs. Research comparing selenium distribution across cattle tissues found significantly higher selenium concentrations in kidney than in liver, heart, spleen, and muscle (9). 

A second bovine organ analysis found the same pattern: kidney contained the highest total selenium concentration among the organs tested (10).

That matters because selenium is required for iodothyronine deiodinases, selenium-containing enzymes involved in activating and metabolizing thyroid hormones (11).

So rather than combining thyroid with liver alone, Thyroid+ adds a naturally selenium-rich organ that complements the nutritional needs of the thyroid system.

→ Our goal isn’t simply to put the named organ in a capsule. We think about the entire nutrient environment that organ system depends on.

That formulation approach is one of the strongest distinctions in heart and soil vs ancestral supplements.

---

2. How Do Sourcing and Testing Compare?

Both brands take quality seriously.

Ancestral states that its products use grass-fed, pasture-raised animals from New Zealand and Australia, are freeze-dried, free of added hormones, and third-party tested for purity (12).

So we would not describe Ancestral as poorly sourced or untested.

Heart & Soil’s additional emphasis is on regenerative agriculture and publicly accessible contaminant testing.

Heart & Soil sources from grass-fed and grass-finished cattle raised on regenerative farms in New Zealand. The farms do not use GMO feed, antibiotics, added hormones, or glyphosate (13). 

We also send samples of both the freeze-dried organs and gelatin capsules for testing for:

• Pesticides
• Heavy metals
• Microbes

Certificates of Analysis are available across the product line (14). 

When considering Heart and Soil vs. Ancestral Supplements, both companies clear a meaningful quality bar.

The distinction is that Heart & Soil puts regenerative farming and public contaminant-testing documentation at the center of its sourcing story.

---

3. Which Brand Is Cheaper?

If price is your only consideration, Ancestral Supplements currently wins several direct comparisons.

At the time of writing:

• Heart & Soil Beef Organs: $52
• Ancestral Grass Fed Beef Organs: $48
• Heart & Soil Her Package: $74
• Ancestral FEM: $68
• Heart & Soil Whole Package: $68
• Ancestral MOFO: $62

Those are current one-time purchase prices rather than subscription promotions. 

But comparing heart and soil vs ancestral supplements by bottle price alone can be misleading.

That’s why we think value should include:

• Price
• Organ dose
• The specific organs included
• Formula design
• Sourcing
• Testing
• Packaging
• Support 

The cheapest bottle and the best fit are not necessarily the same thing.

---

4. What Other Differences Matter?

Packaging and support are smaller differences than formula design, but they may still matter to some shoppers.

Why Does Heart & Soil Use Glass Bottles?

Heart & Soil intentionally packages supplements in glass bottles even though glass costs more, is harder to fill, and is more difficult to ship without breaking (15). 

Heart & Soil also uses real cotton padding inside the bottle.

Ancestral supplements uses plastic bottles, and its public pages don’t clearly state the material of the padding inside the bottle. 

Do Both Brands Offer Personalized Support?

Yes. Ancestral Supplements currently offers a free 1-on-1 email consultation for product and ancestral-living questions (16).

Heart & Soil also offers personalized guidance through its Health Success Team at [email protected]

In addition, Heart & Soil runs a free online community with Health Guides, monthly webcasts and weekly Q&As, challenges, educational resources, accountability, and conversations with other people interested in animal-based nutrition (17). 

The larger community and lifestyle ecosystem is where Heart & Soil adds something different.

---

Which Should You Choose: Heart and Soil vs Ancestral Supplements?

There are legitimate reasons someone might choose either brand.

Ancestral Supplements may appeal to you if you:

• Want the lower current bottle price on several comparable products
• Want a very large catalog of individual organs and glandulars
• Prefer one of its specific formulas

We suggest Heart & Soil if you:

• Value intentionally designed multi-organ formulas
• Prefer glass packaging
• Want regenerative, grass-fed and grass-finished sourcing
• Want publicly accessible contaminant-testing information
• Want access to Health Guides plus a free online nutrition and lifestyle community
• Prefer the specific formulations in products such as Thyroid+, Her Package, or Whole Package

We think the reason to choose Heart & Soil is the combination of intentional formulation, regenerative sourcing, transparent testing, premium packaging, and support beyond the bottle.

---

FAQ

Heart & Soil better vs Ancestral Supplements, which is better?

Both companies offer grass-fed, freeze-dried and third-party-tested organ products. We suggest Heart & Soil for people who place a high value on targeted formula design, regenerative sourcing, contaminant-testing transparency, glass packaging, and access to a broader nutrition and lifestyle community.

Is Ancestral Supplements cheaper than Heart & Soil?

For several directly comparable products, yes. Ancestral currently has a lower one-time price for Grass Fed Beef Organs, FEM, and MOFO than Heart & Soil charges for Beef Organs, Her Package, and Whole Package.

Are Heart & Soil and Ancestral Supplements the same?

No. Although the companies share an ancestral-nutrition philosophy, Heart and Soil vs Ancestral Supplements differ in product formulas, sourcing emphasis, packaging, pricing, and the broader services around the products.

Does Ancestral Supplements third-party test its products?

Yes. Current Ancestral product pages state that products are third-party tested for purity. Heart & Soil also uses independent testing and publishes product-specific contaminant-testing documentation.

What makes Heart & Soil formulas different?

Heart & Soil often combines like-supports-like organ nutrition with other organs selected for their nutrient profile. Thyroid+ is a good example: it combines thyroid and liver with kidney, a bovine organ that contains selenium, a mineral involved in thyroid hormone metabolism. 

---

Related Reading

• Learn more in our Ultimate Guide to the Animal-Based Diet
• Read our guide to Grass-Fed Thyroid+ and thyroid nutrition
• Explore the timeless benefits of bone broth and nose-to-tail nutrition.

---

The Bottom Line

The Heart and Soil vs Ancestral Supplements comparison is closer than you might expect.

Both companies make grass-fed, freeze-dried organ supplements. Both use third-party testing. Both offer personalized guidance. And Ancestral is currently cheaper on several straightforward product comparisons.

What sets Heart & Soil apart is glass packaging, regenerative sourcing, and intentional combinations of organs built around specific body systems and complementary nutrients. We also surround our supplements with Health Guides, education, and a free online community.

So if the lowest upfront price is your main priority, Ancestral Supplements may make sense.

But if you’re looking at formula design, sourcing, testing transparency, packaging, and the broader health ecosystem together, we suggest Heart & Soil.